Hexagram 43 — Break-through (Guai)
Hexagram 43, Parting (Guai), is Marsh above Heaven: water rising toward heaven, the image of a decisive separation that must be done with care. It describes how to remove a person, a practice or a party that has been allowed to remain too long, and the judgement supplies a four-part sequence to make the removal legible rather than arbitrary.
The Shape of the Hexagram
- Upper trigram
- Lake (Dui) — Metal
- Lower trigram
- Heaven (Qian) — Metal
- Line pattern
- 1:yang, 2:yang, 3:yang, 4:yang, 5:yang, 6:yin
- Element
- Earth
Marsh above Heaven: water rising toward heaven, the image of a decisive separation. Earth governs this palace, so the parting must be well-announced; a swift move without warning risks sympathy with the one being separated, which defeats the purpose of the decision.
The Judgment (Gua Ci)
Kwâi requires (in him who would fulfil its meaning) the exhibition (of the culprit's guilt) in the royal court, and a sincere and earnest appeal (for sympathy and support), with a consciousness of the peril (involved in cutting off the criminal). He should (also) make announcement in his own city, and show that it will not be well to have recourse at once to arms. (In this way) there will be advantage in whatever he shall go forward to.
James Legge, 1882, Sacred Books of the East, Vol. 16 (public domain).
Show the culprit's guilt in the royal court, appeal sincerely for sympathy, make announcement in your own city, and show that you will not resort to arms too soon. The four-part instruction distinguishes the correct order: announce, appeal, warn, then act. Each step matters for the outcome.
(The trigram representing) heaven and that for the waters of a marsh mounting above it form Kwâi. The superior man, in accordance with this, bestows emolument on those below him, and dislikes allowing his gifts to accumulate (undispensed).
The Image, same source.
The superior man bestows emolument on those below him and dislikes allowing his gifts to accumulate undispensed. Parting becomes necessary when gifts stop flowing, so the hexagram also urges generosity as a preventive: distribute before you need to separate.
What It Means in Practice
- Manifest your strength in your toes — you will not succeed. The first line forbids decisive action taken from below. You may know the removal is necessary, but taking it without authority and visibility will fail because no one else will follow. Announce before you move.
- Appeal sincerely and be full of apprehension, with hostile measures possible late at night. The second line's combination of sincerity and apprehension is necessary for decisive action; if you are too confident, you misjudge resistance, and if you are too tentative, you lose momentum. Apprehension is a resource here, not a flaw.
- Walk alone and encounter the rain until you are hated by proper associates. The third line is the price of decisive separation: you cannot please everyone. The superior man walks alone in rain and is hated, but in the end there is no blame because the separation was necessary and the announcement was honest.
- Skin stripped from the buttocks, walking with difficulty, like a sheep led after its companions: if you hear these words and do not believe them, you are about to make the fourth line's mistake. Listen to the caution before deciding the speed of the separation. Too fast produces resentment; too slow produces decay.
The Six Lines
- Line 1 — Strength in the toes. No success.
The first NINE, undivided, shows its subject in (the pride of) strength advancing with his toes. He goes forward, but will not succeed. There will be ground for blame.
- Line 2 — Apprehension, appeal. Late-night hostility.
The second NINE, undivided, shows its subject full of apprehension and appealing (for sympathy and help). Late at night hostile measures may be (taken against him), but he need not be anxious about them.
- Line 3 — Strong looks, walk alone in rain. Eventually no blame.
The third NINE, undivided, shows its subject (about to advance) with strong (and determined) looks. There will be evil. (But) the superior man, bent on cutting off (the criminal), will walk alone and encounter the rain, (till he be hated by his proper associates) as if he were contaminated (by the others). (In the end) there will be no blame against him.
- Line 4 — Skin stripped, walk with difficulty.
The fourth NINE, undivided, shows one from whose buttocks the skin has been stripped, and who walks slowly and with difficulty. (If he could act) like. a sheep led (after its companions), occasion for repentance would disappear. But though he hear these words, he will not believe them.
- Line 5 — Uproot purslain. Central position. No error.
The fifth NINE, undivided, shows (the small men like) a bed of purslain, which ought to be uprooted with the utmost determination. (The subject of the line having such determination), his action, in harmony with his central position, will lead to no error or blame.
- Line 6 — No helpers. Evil end.
The sixth SIX, divided, shows its subject without any (helpers) on whom to call. His end will be evil.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Hexagram 43 mean about removing a leader or practice?
It supplies a four-part sequence: announce the guilt publicly, appeal sincerely for sympathy, warn in your own city, and show you will not resort to arms too soon. The purpose is to make the removal legible, so that it is seen as a correct decision rather than a factional one. Each step must follow the previous one.
Why bestow emolument and distribute gifts?
Because parting becomes necessary when gifts stop flowing down and accumulate above. The superior man dislikes accumulated gifts because accumulation creates resentment and makes the eventual separation harder. Generosity is preventive: distribute before you need to separate.
What does "show that arms will not be used too soon" mean?
It means keep the threat of force behind, even when force is justified. The judgement says show that arms will not be used, not that they will not be used at all. The visible restraint makes the earlier announcement of guilt more credible; if you resort to arms before showing the reason, you lose the sympathy you need.
How is Hexagram 43 related to Hexagram 44?
They are exact inverses of each other. Marsh above Heaven becomes Wind under Heaven when every line is reversed, and decisive separation becomes a new arrival. The pair describes one season in two phases: the moment to end a course, and the moment the new course appears.